Welcome to The Irish Coffee Pub
Discover the charm of The Irish Coffee Pub, a cozy Irish pub in East Islip, NY, offering a delightful dining experience. With a wide range of amenities including outdoor seating, a full bar, and catering services, this pub is perfect for group gatherings or a casual dinner. Indulge in starters like Fresh Mozzarella Burrata or Pepper Seared Ahi Tuna, and savor comforting soups like French Onion. Customer reviews rave about the friendly staff, delicious food like Jumbo Shrimp Guinness, and memorable events like the Yuletide celebration. Don't miss out on the warm ambiance and flavorful dishes at The Irish Coffee Pub.
-
131 Carleton Ave East Islip, NY 11730131 Carleton Ave East Islip, NY 11730 Hotline: (631) 277-0007
Welcome to The Irish Coffee Pub, a charming establishment nestled at 131 Carleton Ave in East Islip, NY. This pub is not just a dining spot; it's an experience where the warmth of Irish hospitality meets a palette of delightful flavors. With a rich menu featuring classics like the iconic Fish & Chips, alongside an array of delectable entrees and salads, every visit promises to be a memorable one.
The ambiance here is inviting and cozy, with various rooms that evoke a sense of home. As soon as you step through the doors, you are greeted by friendly staff whose attentiveness shines without being intrusive—a hallmark of great service. One cannot overlook the freshly baked soda bread served warm, a simple yet delightful start to any meal.
During lunch, the Monterey Salad stands out for its vibrant combination of baby spinach, juicy strawberries, and crispy honey pecans, while the Clam Casino Royale is a must-try starter with its perfect blend of garlic, herbs, and rich flavors topped with bacon and Parmesan. Moving to dinner, the Chicken Harrington is packed with flavor, featuring a tender breast poached in fine Chardonnay and topped with a luxurious mushroom cream sauce—a true comfort food experience.
Patrons consistently rave about the Jumbo Shrimp Guinness, served with a variety of dipping sauces that enhance the fresh, flavorful shrimp. And should you have room, the selection of desserts, highlighted by a rich assortment of coffees, makes for a perfect endnote to your meal.
Events at The Irish Coffee Pub are celebrated throughout the year, each offering a unique opportunity to gather and enjoy something special, enhancing the community feel. Whether it's a festive Yuletide celebration or a casual Father's Day dinner, diners can always expect top-notch dishes served with a smile.
Visitors have frequently shared their favorite memories of dining here, emphasizing not only the quality of food but also the overall welcoming vibe that the pub radiates. As one satisfied customer summed it up perfectly, "You won’t be disappointed." If you're seeking a combination of hearty Irish fare and a warm atmosphere, The Irish Coffee Pub is just the place to indulge your cravings.
They never ever disappoint. From the onset, their staff are all so friendly & attentive but not overbearing. Their homemade baked bread & scones are all delicious especially the soda bread. Love their Jumbo Shrimp Guinness which comes with steamed veggies & choice of potato. This time I chose for the dipping sauces...cocktail sauce, tartar sauce & their lemon beurre blanc which were all soooo good. Had no room for dessert but they do have a wide variety to choose from along with various coffees. The restaurant itself is really nice with many different rooms within. The weekends are crowded so be sure to make a reservation. Check out the menu & specials online and give it a try, you won't be disappointed. Enjoy!!!
Every year they have many amazing celebrations. The one we look forward to the most is the Yuletide. It's a gathering like no other, it's not
One of our favorite restaurants. Father's Day Dinner there yesterday. A bit of a wait to be served, but the food was well worth the wait. I had the Filet Mignon Au Poivre (brandy peppercorn glaze) Super yummy. My favorite. Wish I had their recipe. While hubby was waiting for his Corned Beef and Cabbage, he wolfed down a bowl of the most delicious potato soup. One son made short work of his Beef Barley soup. Staff were very friendly and accommodating and took care of special menu for the grand children. And of course, we always enjoy the Irish Waterford crystal and other collectibles on display there. The ambiance is very welcoming. We will be back !!!
This is one of my favorite restaurants. If I lived closer, I would come here more frequently. As soon as you walk in, you get a comfortable and welcoming vibe. The staff goes above and beyond and you never feel rushed (even when they are busy). I wish I remembered the servers name! He was awesome and I loved his Irish brogue. The food is fresh and delicious. In my recent visit, I enjoyed the cheeseburger with caramelized onions and fries but it seems like you can't go wrong with anything you order. Every dish I have ever tried has been delicious! Yum! Can't wait to return!
We were lucky enough to have some Irish Coffee Pub catering on Christmas Day. Our family loves the braised steak burgundy since it's so tender and flavorful (it can also be prepared gluten free), the roasted potatoes, and the grilled vegetables. Their dishes help to elevate our Christmas dinner and satisfy a variety of palates.
I attended a wedding rehearsal dinner at the Irish Coffee Pub a few weeks ago. It was a large gathering, over 50 attendees. The Irish Coffee Pub staff ran the event smoothly and professionally. The food was also on point. They are well prepared to host multiple events with their room layouts.
Absolutely perfect dinner for four in a Wednesday night . The room is lovely and inviting. Waiter Jacob was outstanding and made sure we all had everything we needed to enjoy the meal. Perfect dirty martini, delicious corned beef and cabbage for me, and 2 guests enjoyed the salmon. My partner enjoyed a chicken dish. All the meals were brought to the table hot and placed in front of us simultaneously. Very impressed with the care the staff took to get hot meals to the table. The bread basket comes to the table first, filled with scones and brown bread like your Irish grandmother would make. We crowned the meal with a trip to the bar for Irish coffee. So wonderful to have it made right with a proper float of semi whipped cream. The bartender is gracious and very capable. Thank you all for a perfect dining experience.
This was my first time after the Irish Coffee Pub, although my families been coming for years and with reason. We came for a party in the upstairs, Bay Shore FD Annual Patrol Dinner. Huge party room with dance floor, fireplace and bar. Food was fabulous, buffet style, there were servers moving swiftly about and they were super responsive to any requests. #TommyDuck was the one man band and that's all we needed. The downstairs has a warm inviting atmosphere and what sounded like a live piano playing, can't wait to come back and check it out!
Attended a medical conference in a nice room of windows set up for about 50. Multiple rooms that looked as quaint as grammy's tea room. The staff handled the group with ease as this seems to be a popular venue for groups & gatherings. Large parking lot, right off the highway. The standard chicken beef fish choices were prepared nicely and looked quite professional plated. While we would not visit for a regular dinner adventure, I absolutely recommend a gathering or business event here.